(Tax Update) Is Charging Management Fees Really a Smart Way to Lower Your Company’s Profit?

(Tax Update) Is Charging Management Fees Really a Smart Way to Lower Your Company’s Profit?

In Malaysia, a management fee typically refers to payments for services like strategic planning, operational management, financial oversight, and administrative tasks provided by one entity to another. Usually, these fees are charged within corporate groups or by specialized management firms.

But what if the management fee isn't quite what it seems? Let me share a true story from a recent experience.

The Curious Case of a Suspicious Management Fee

Last month, I reviewed the financial statements of one of my SME clients, and an unusual entry caught my attention—a substantial sum labeled "Management Fees." Management fees aren't unusual, especially within corporate groups.

But here's the twist: This client didn't have subsidiaries, parent companies, or any affiliated entities at all.

My curiosity got the better of me, so I asked the client directly, "Who exactly is receiving this management fee?"

After some hesitation, the client confessed that the recipient wasn't a company but just one individual. Alarm bells immediately went off in my head. I've seen this scenario before—and so has LHDN, Malaysia’s tax authority.

Yes, a management fee can be paid to an individual in Malaysia, but you must be very cautious.

The individual receiving the fee must genuinely provide management-related services (e.g., strategic planning, operational oversight, financial advice). Paying fees without clear evidence of services provided could lead to disallowance by LHDN.

A Cautionary Tale from a Fellow SME Owner

Few years back, I advised another SME owner—Mr Tan. He thought he'd discovered a clever solution to reduce his company's taxable profits by charging hefty management fees. His documentation, however, was rojak—a single-page agreement without clear explanations or proof of services rendered.

Soon enough, LHDN auditors came knocking, and Mr Tan faced tough questions:

  • "Can you show us detailed proof of these management services?"

  • "How were these fees calculated?"

  • "What specific management services were delivered?"

With nothing concrete to show, the auditors swiftly concluded that the management fees were not legitimate business expenses but sham transactions designed to reduce taxable income artificially.

The fees were disallowed, and Mr Tan ended up with additional taxes, penalties, sleepless nights, and substantial stress.

This cautionary tale underscores why SMEs must handle management fees carefully.

Common Pitfalls SMEs Face with Management Fees

Before you implement management fees, be aware of these critical red flags that attract tax scrutiny:

1. Lack of Clear Documentation

When management fees aren't backed by thorough documentation, they easily appear illegitimate or questionable to auditors. Poor documentation signals possible sham transactions or tax evasion.

2. Base Erosion Concerns

Excessively high management fees significantly lower taxable profits, raising suspicion about deliberate tax minimization efforts.

3. Transfer Pricing Risks

Transactions involving related parties must always reflect market rates (arm's length). Failure to adhere to this principle can trigger transfer pricing audits and penalties.

4. Sham Transactions

Fees paid without actual services being rendered are classic examples of sham transactions, explicitly used to evade tax. These arrangements almost always end poorly during audits.

A Deeper Dive into the Arm’s Length Principle (with Examples)

Simply put, the arm’s length principle requires related-party transactions to reflect terms as if the parties were independent. For example:

  • Acceptable: Your management fee matches industry benchmarks, reflecting market rates based on clear evidence.

  • Problematic: Paying significantly higher fees without clear market justification, particularly to relatives or connected parties.

Ensure your fee structure mirrors what you'd reasonably expect to pay an unrelated, external firm for the same services. Regular benchmarking can help you maintain compliance.

A Practical Checklist for Charging Management Fees the Right Way:

Follow these 10 simple steps to stay compliant:

  1. Draft Clear Agreements

    • Clearly specify scope, deliverables, timelines, and responsibilities.

  2. Maintain Detailed Records

    • Keep logs of meetings, tasks, communications, and tangible results.

  3. Adhere to Market Rates

    • Benchmark your fees against industry standards annually.

  4. Ensure Proof of Service Delivery

    • Document work completed, hours logged, or outcomes clearly.

  5. Transparency in Financial Reporting

    • Clearly identify management fee transactions in your financial statements.

  6. Regular Internal Reviews

    • Conduct periodic internal audits to ensure compliance.

  7. Service Tax Compliance

    • Register and report accurately if your services are taxable.

  8. Educate Your Team

    • Ensure financial staff understand compliance rules fully.

  9. Seek Independent Advice

    • Get external validation or third-party benchmarking periodically.

  10. Update Documentation Regularly

  • Revise your agreements regularly to reflect actual business changes.

Real-Life Scenario: Doing it Right

Here's an example of an SME owner doing it correctly:

Madam Lee operates a thriving SME with a proper group structure. Her business pays monthly management fees to her holding company. The holding company provides genuine strategic guidance, financial oversight, and administrative services.

Every month, detailed records clearly outline the management tasks performed, the time invested by personnel, and the tangible outcomes achieved for the SME. The management service agreement between Madam Lee’s SME and her holding company is comprehensive, clearly stating responsibilities, deliverables, and payment terms.

She regularly benchmarks these fees against market rates, ensuring they remain transparent, justified, and compliant with Malaysia’s transfer pricing regulations.

Because of her meticulous approach, Madam Lee faces no sleepless nights worrying about audits or tax penalties. When LHDN comes knocking, she confidently presents all necessary documentation, agreements, and evidence of actual services rendered.

Her approach highlights precisely how SMEs can leverage management fees effectively while staying fully compliant.

Final Thoughts for SME Bosses

Management fees can indeed help you manage profits and taxes effectively. But remember:

  • Clarity beats shortcuts.

  • Documentation prevents audits.

  • Transparency ensures peace of mind.

Doing it right is always better than doing it easy. Protect your business by staying genuine, transparent, and fully compliant.

Selamat Hari Raya.

Visit Us

  • Wisma KTP, 53 Jalan Molek 1/8, Taman Molek, 81100 Johor Bahru

  • Wisma THK, 41, Jalan Molek 1/8, Taman Molek, 81100 Johor Bahru

KTP (Audit, Tax, Advisory)

An approved audit firm and licensed tax firm operating under the KTP group based in Johor Bahru providing audit, tax planning, advisory and compliance services to clients

THK (Secretarial, Bookkeeping, Payroll, Advisory)

A licensed secretarial firm in Johor Bahru providing fast reliable incorporation, secretarial services, corporate compliance services, outsourcing bookkeeping, and payroll services to clients

KTP Lifestyle

An internal community for our colleagues on work and leisure.

KTP Career

An external job community on vacancies in Johor Bahru for interns, graduates & experienced candidates.

#Thk

#KTP


taxKtp KtpManagement fee